Spring 2009 -- CMN 280, Prof. Sandvig
 
     Home + About + Schedule + Readings + Assignments + Help/Handouts + Grades + Blogs

Textually Active

BLOG POST: The Norm Experiment

Part I:
FREQUENT UPDATES: Pick either an acquaintance you don't know that well or a parent. In a 24 hour period dramatically increase the amount of information you send this person using a text-based mobile communication technology that you know they can receive (likeIM on your phone, text/SMS, or e-mail on your phone/PDA). For example, you could communicate with them every time you do anything ("hi I am getting on the bus", "arrived in class," "class is boring," "having lunch," "talking with friend.") Describe the reactions.

Part II:
I decided to text my friend’s sister because I am not very close with her and do not know her very well. I usually only call her if I need to get ahold of my friend. Whenever I have seen this girl, she is always texting and always has her phone right next to her so I knew she would be an ideal person to test. Unlike an adult, or even an infrequent text-er might ignore such text messages.

Me: Finished with class for the day!
Her: [No Reply]
Me: I’m gonna go to Walgreens
Her: I think you have the wrong person…
Me: Ugh, I’m so tired! I’m going to take a nap
Her: Alright…I’m confused
Me: Up from my nap! I’m going to go make some food
Her: [No Reply]
Me: There’s nothing on TV!
Her: Ohkk? Why did you need to tell me that?!
Me: I’m starting my homework.
Her: Do you know who this is?!
Me: I have so much to do!!
Her: [No Reply]
---Now it is about 1AM---
Me: I’m so tired!
Her: Are you on something??
Me: I have a headache!
Her: [No Reply]
Me: Alright, I’m going to sleep! Good night!
Her: [No Reply]

While doing this experiment, it was very difficult to restrain from responding to the other person’s replies. I think that the first text that she received, she thought she got it in error because she did not reply to me. As the day went on, I think she got more and more confused. I have never texted anyone such mundane details of my life. After I was finished doing the experiment, I had to tell her why I was texting her all of these details! She laughed and said she was very relieved because she thought I was going crazy.

Part III
One of the norms that I was breaking in this experiment was that we communicate when we have something semi-interesting to say. The things that I was texting to my subject were very boring and no one (especially someone that I am not close with) needs to hear the things that I texted to her. My phone has a certain text message limit that it can hold as well as a certain amount of text messages allowed on my plan. If I texted everyone in my phonebook the same way that I texted my subject, I would be in trouble. Also, I think that if I texted this much information to many people, my phone would break down because of too much usage!

Another norm that I broke was that we communicate (in this case, text) with people that we are close to unless we have some sort of purpose. The only people that I might text the kind of information I texted to my subject would be if I was really close with them. Sometimes my best friend texts me random things from her day and I make fun of her because I think that what she tells me is totally unnecessary. Also, texting is a great tool to send things without talking. If I have a quick question about something in a class and I want to ask someone in my class… I will text them. Or if I am in class, and cannot break the social norm of answering my phone in class, I will text someone to tell them the information that I am trying to convey. So, the design of text messages, although they have their own social rules and norms, helps to solve some of the other problems of other communication technology.

12 Mar16:13

Peer Review

By ChattyCathy

I really enjoyed your post! The inclusion of the actual texting dialogue was not only useful for illustration purposes, but also very funny and entertaining.

I might ask you to consider if you thought any person you texted this amount would have reacted in a similar way, or was it just unique to her? Or if it had been an adult, do you think he or she would have been more cordial? Or perhaps not responded at all? Just a few thoughts for discussion sake. :)

I also completely agree with your two social norms. I had a similar experiment in which I facebooked people RELENTLESSLY and wrote all over their walls- one post after the next after the next. I got similar reactions of confusion and annoyance. You elaborated on your social norms well too. I feel that I could get a clear understanding of what you were thinking and your train of thought. Overall, I think it was a great post. Well done!

Go to the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign homepage. Go to the top of this page.
Comments to csandvig@uiuc.edu.